Crisp and Golden Mac and Cheese Cakes on the Grill
Turn yesterday's leftover macaroni into today's crispy, golden side dish with this easy wood-fired recipe.
For superior flavor and versatility, a flat top griddle grill consistently outperforms traditional open grates. The solid carbon steel surface prevents juices from dripping onto coals, which eliminates dangerous flare-ups and retains moisture within the meat. This design allows for 100% surface contact, creating a deeper Maillard reaction (the savory crust) and enables you to cook breakfast batters, vegetables, and large cuts of meat simultaneously on a single unit.
The primary advantage of a flat top grill is the enhancement of flavor through the Maillard reaction. On a traditional grate grill, your food only makes contact with the hot metal on the specific grate lines. This means you are only searing about 30% of the steak or burger, while the rest cooks via indirect air heat.
A griddle surface provides contact with the entire surface area of the food. This results in a uniform, golden-brown sear across the entire cut of meat. Furthermore, because the juices do not drip away into the fire, the meat cooks in its own flavorful fats, keeping it tender and juicy.
Pro Tip: The Steakhouse Sear
For the perfect medium-rare steak on a griddle, rely on the "contact sear." Place your steak on the hottest part of the griddle for 2-3 minutes per side to build a crust that traditional grates simply cannot achieve. Finish it on a cooler zone to reach internal temp without burning the exterior.
When deciding between a traditional BBQ and a griddle (or a hybrid like the Arteflame), consider how the cooking surface affects the outcome.
| Feature | Flat Top Griddle (Arteflame) | Traditional Grate Grill |
|---|---|---|
| Heat Consistency | Even heat distribution; distinct temperature zones. | Hot spots and cool spots; susceptible to wind. |
| Flavor Profile | Juicy; deep sear over 100% of surface. | Smoky; char marks only on grate lines. |
| Flare-Ups | None (Solid surface blocks drips). | Frequent (Fat drips onto flames). |
| Versatility | High (Eggs, pancakes, rice, steak, veggies). | Low (Large meats and skewers only). |
| Cleaning | Scrape and go (Minutes). | Scrubbing wire brushes (Labor intensive). |
One of the biggest limiting factors of standard grills is the gap between the grates. Vegetables, shrimp, and delicate fish often fall through into the fire. A flat top griddle removes this limitation entirely.
Because the surface is solid, you can turn your outdoor grill into a complete kitchen. You can wake up and cook bacon, eggs, and pancakes outdoors. For lunch, smash burgers sear perfectly in their own juices. For dinner, you can grill asparagus and potatoes right alongside a ribeye without needing a separate pan or grill basket.

Cooking on a griddle can offer distinct health advantages regarding carcinogens. When fat drips from meat onto an open flame (as with traditional grates), it causes flare-ups. The smoke produced by burning fat contains Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) and Heterocyclic Amines (HCAs), which are potentially carcinogenic compounds that adhere back onto the food.
A solid griddle surface prevents fat from dripping directly into the fire. The fat is instead channeled away or used to sear the meat, significantly reducing the formation of these harmful smoke compounds.
Pro Tip: Seasoning is Key
Much like a cast-iron skillet, a carbon steel griddle builds up a seasoning layer of polymerized oil over time. This creates a natural, non-stick surface that allows you to cook with less added oil or butter, further improving the health profile of your meals.
No, it is generally easier than a grate grill. You simply scrape the residue into the fire or grease catch while the unit is still hot, wipe it down with a little oil, and you are done. There is no need for wire brushes or removing grates to soak.
Yes, especially with wood-fired griddles like the Arteflame. While the food cooks on a solid surface, the open center allows wood smoke to circulate around the food, providing that authentic campfire flavor without the char of direct flame contact.
If left unseasoned and exposed to elements, it can rust, but this is easily fixable. Carbon steel is very durable; simply scrub the rust off with steel wool, heat the grill, and re-season with oil to restore the surface to new condition.