Authentic Indiana Amish Grilled Chicken Wings on the Arteflame

Introduction

There is something undeniably comforting about the rustic, hearty flavors of the American Midwest. If you have ever wandered through an Indiana county fair or stopped by a roadside stand in Amish country, you know the scent—savory, buttery, and perfectly charred. These Indiana Amish Grilled Chicken Wings are not defined by fiery heat or heavy tomato-based sauces; rather, they are celebrated for a rich, savory depth created by a simple yet magical combination of soy sauce, dried mustard, and garlic. It is a flavor profile that feels like home, even if you are miles away.

Recreating this classic recipe on an Arteflame grill elevates the experience entirely. While the traditional method often involves deep frying, using the Arteflame allow us to achieve that coveted crispy skin on the center sear grate, while the flat cooktop locks in the juices as the wings finish cooking. The result is a smoky, golden-brown masterpiece that pays homage to tradition while embracing the joy of outdoor grilling. This recipe yields wings that are tender on the inside, impossibly crisp on the outside, and coated in a savory butter glaze that is impossible to resist.

Ingredients

The Meat

• 5 lbs Chicken Wings (party style, separated into drums and flats)

The Marinade & Glaze

• 2 cups Water
• 1 cup Soy Sauce
• 1 tbsp Dried Ground Mustard
• 1 tbsp Garlic Powder
• 1 tsp Sea Salt
• 1 tsp Freshly Cracked Black Pepper
• 1/2 cup Unsalted Butter (melted, for finishing)
• High-heat cooking oil (such as Peanut or Avocado oil) for the grill surface

Instructions

Step 1: Prepare the Savory Marinade

1. In a large mixing bowl or a heavy-duty resealable bag, combine the water and soy sauce.
2. Whisk in the dried ground mustard, garlic powder, sea salt, and black pepper until fully dissolved and incorporated.
3. Add the chicken wings to the mixture, ensuring they are completely submerged.
4. Seal the bag or cover the bowl and refrigerate. For the best flavor penetration, marinate for at least 3 hours, though overnight is preferred to let the soy and mustard tenderize the meat.

Step 2: Fire Up the Arteflame

1. Build a medium-sized fire in the center of your Arteflame grill using hardwood charcoal or seasoned wood.
2. Allow the grill to heat up for about 20 minutes. You want the center grill grate to be searing hot (around 600°F+) and the flat carbon steel cooktop to reach a steady roasting temperature (around 400°F).
3. Lightly oil the flat cooktop surface to ensure a non-stick cooking experience.

Step 3: Grill to Perfection

1. Remove the wings from the marinade and pat them dry with paper towels. Discard the used marinade.
2. Place the wings directly on the flat steel cooktop, arranging them in a circle around the fire. This allows them to cook evenly without burning.
3. Grill the wings for 20-25 minutes, turning them occasionally to crisp up all sides.
4. For an extra char, move the wings onto the center grill grate for the last 2 minutes of cooking, searing the skin until bubbly and golden.

Step 4: The Final Butter Toss

1. While the wings are finishing on the grill, place a small heat-safe sauce pot on the outer edge of the cooktop to melt the butter.
2. Once the wings are fully cooked (internal temperature of 165°F), transfer them immediately into a large clean bowl.
3. Pour the melted butter over the hot wings and toss vigorously to coat them in that rich, velvety glaze. Serve immediately.

Tips

To master these Indiana Amish wings, patience is your best ingredient. The magic of this recipe lies in the marinade; the longer the chicken sits in the soy and mustard mixture, the deeper the savory flavor penetrates the meat. Do not rush the drying process before grilling—wet wings will steam rather than crisp. Pat them down thoroughly before they hit the hot steel of the Arteflame.

When cooking on the Arteflame, utilize the heat zones effectively. Start the wings on the cooler outer ring if your fire is blazing too hot, then gradually move them closer to the center to crisp the skin. If you want to replicate the traditional "double-cooked" texture without deep frying, you can let the wings rest for five minutes after the first fifteen minutes of grilling, then throw them back on the hottest part of the cooktop for a final high-heat sear.

Variations

While the classic Amish recipe is strictly savory, the neutral base of soy and butter makes it incredibly easy to customize. You can adjust the flavor profile to suit your guests without losing the heart of the dish. Here are a few ways to twist the tradition:

• Sweet & Savory: Add 2 tablespoons of honey or maple syrup to the final melted butter toss for a caramelized finish.
• The Heat Seeker: Mix 1 teaspoon of cayenne pepper or crushed red pepper flakes into the dry spice rub for a subtle kick.
• Herbal Infusion: Add fresh rosemary or thyme sprigs to the melting butter on the grill for an aromatic, earthy note.
• Garlic Lover’s Dream: Double the garlic powder and add minced fresh garlic to the butter glaze.
• Citrus Zest: Squeeze fresh lemon juice over the finished wings to cut through the richness of the butter and soy.

Best pairings

These wings are rich and salty, so they pair best with sides that offer a refreshing crunch or a slightly sweet contrast. In classic Indiana fashion, you cannot go wrong with a creamy, vinegar-based coleslaw to cut through the savory butter glaze. A side of warm, cast-iron cornbread cooked right on the Arteflame flat top is also an excellent companion, soaking up any extra sauce.

For beverages, stick to crisp and refreshing options. An ice-cold pilsner or a light lager works wonders as a palate cleanser between bites. If you prefer non-alcoholic options, a classic freshly brewed iced tea with a wedge of lemon provides the perfect acidic balance to the soy-based seasoning. Keep the sides simple and let the wings be the star of the show.

Conclusion

These Indiana Amish Grilled Chicken Wings are a testament to the power of simplicity. By using a few high-quality ingredients and the superior searing capabilities of the Arteflame grill, you transform humble chicken wings into a gourmet experience that resonates with history and comfort. The combination of the salty soy marinade and the rich butter finish creates a flavor profile that is distinct, addictive, and crowd-pleasing.

Whether you are hosting a backyard barbecue or simply looking for a new family favorite, this recipe delivers perfectly every time. The sizzle of the flat top, the aroma of garlic and butter, and the satisfaction of sharing good food with great people—that is what grilling is all about. Fire up your grill and bring a taste of the heartland to your table.