Best Pizza in Colorado Springs: Top 5 Spots Ranked [2026 List] | Arteflame

Introduction

Finding the perfect slice in the shadow of Pikes Peak can be overwhelming with so many options popping up. Whether you are hunting for a foldable New York slice, a crispy New Haven crust, or a gourmet wood-fired experience, Colorado Springs has evolved into a legitimate pizza destination. We have scoured the city to bring you the definitive guide to the local dough-and-cheese scene. However, even the best takeout can get cold on the drive home. That is why we are also revealing how you can surpass restaurant quality right in your backyard using the Arteflame grill.

• The Top 5 Pizza Ranking
• Compare the Slices
• The "Restaurant-Quality" Secret
• Why Use an Arteflame?

Best Pizza in Colorado Springs

Key Takeaways

• Slice420 is the go-to for authentic, foldable New York style.
• White Pie brings the charred perfection of New Haven style to the Springs.
• Fat Sully's offers the best value with their massive, shareable slices.
• Pizzeria Rustica provides a high-end, authentic Neapolitan experience.
• Bambino's is best for customizing your own personal pizzas.

Where to Get the Best Pizza in Colorado Springs?

The best pizza in Colorado Springs combines high-altitude dough management with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Top-rated establishments like Slice420 and White Pie distinguish themselves through 72-hour dough fermentation processes and the use of high-heat ovens that create the perfect balance between a crispy, charred crust and a chewy interior.

Slice420
If you are a purist looking for that classic NYC flop, Slice420 is the undisputed champion in town. We found their sauce to have the perfect tang-to-sweet ratio, and the crust holds up beautifully under a heavy layer of pepperoni.

White Pie
For those who appreciate a char, White Pie delivers excellent New Haven-style pizza. In our testing, their clam pizza stood out as a unique, savory option that rivals anything you would find on the East Coast.

Fat Sully's
When size matters, Fat Sully's delivers. Their "giant" slices are not a gimmick; the dough is flavorful and thin. It is the perfect spot for late-night cravings or feeding a large group on a budget.

Pizzeria Rustica
Located in Old Colorado City, this spot offers an authentic Neapolitan experience. We love their dedication to the craft—using wood-fired ovens to blister the crust in seconds, preserving the fresh mozzarella and basil flavors.

Comparison: Which Slice is Right for You?

How to Make the Best Pizza at Home

I used to think my backyard pizzas were passable, until I realized I was essentially baking them slowly on a standard grate instead of searing them with the intensity of a professional oven. The moment I switched to a solid steel cooktop, the crust transformed from dry and biscuit-like to blistered, chewy, and perfectly charred.

You do not need a brick oven in your kitchen to achieve Pizzeria Rustica quality. By using an Arteflame grill, you can replicate—and often exceed—the results of the top spots in Colorado Springs.

The "Searing" Technique

The Arteflame Grill excels at pizza making because it mimics the intense heat of a professional pizza oven. Here is why it changes the game:

1. 1,000°F Sear: The solid steel cooktop reaches temperatures over 1,000°F, allowing you to flash-sear the crust instantly, locking in moisture while creating a crispy bottom.
2. Grill All Food at Once: Unlike a standard pizza oven that fits one pie, the Arteflame allows you to grill toppings (like sausages, peppers, and onions) on the flat top while the pizza cooks, ensuring every ingredient is perfectly caramelized.
3. Social Grill: The open fire design means you are not stuck in the kitchen; you are outside with your guests.

Pro Tip: If you do not have time to make dough from scratch, head to the Costco on N Nevada Ave or Barnes Rd. Buying fresh, uncooked pizzas from Costco provides an excellent base. We recommend taking them home, adding your own gourmet toppings (like prosciutto or fresh basil), and firing them on your Arteflame using the Pizza Oven attachment for a smokey, wood-fired upgrade that tastes entirely homemade.

Why We Call It The "Social Grill"

An Arteflame grill is not just a cooking appliance; it is a hosting tool. Its circular design invites friends and family to gather around the fire 360 degrees. Instead of the chef being isolated against a wall or hidden in the kitchen, everyone can stand around the warmth of the fire, watching the pizza bubble and char. It turns a simple dinner into an interactive event.