Grilled Connecticut-Style Lobster Rolls: The Ultimate Warm Butter Recipe

There is an age-old debate along the coast of New England regarding the proper way to serve a lobster roll. While Maine boasts a cold salad dressed in mayonnaise, the Connecticut-style lobster roll is the undisputed champion of savory indulgence. This version serves the meat warm, drenched in melted butter, highlighting the natural sweetness of the lobster without masking it with heavy condiments. Cooking this on an Arteflame grill elevates the experience entirely; the flat cooktop provides the perfect surface to toast your split-top buns to golden perfection while simultaneously keeping a bath of butter warm and inviting for the lobster meat. It is a simple preparation that relies heavily on the quality of ingredients and the precise heat control of your grill. Whether you are hosting a summer seafood boil or just craving a taste of the coast, this warm, buttery delicacy delivers pure comfort in every bite.

Ingredients

The Essentials

• 1.5 lbs cooked lobster meat (knuckle and claw meat is preferred for texture)
• 1 stick (1/2 cup) unsalted butter, high quality
• 4 New England-style split-top hot dog buns
• 1/2 teaspoon Old Bay seasoning (optional, for a kick)
• 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
• 1 tablespoon fresh chives, finely chopped
• 1 clove garlic, smashed (optional, to infuse the butter)
• Sea salt and freshly cracked black pepper to taste
• Lettuce leaves (Bibb or Butter lettuce), optional for garnish

Instructions

Step 1: Fire Up the Arteflame

1. Start your Arteflame grill by building a medium-sized fire in the center. Allow the fire to burn down slightly so the center griddle plate reaches a medium-high cooking temperature.
2. Clean the cooktop surface with a scraper and apply a very thin layer of vegetable oil to ensure it is seasoned and ready for cooking.
3. Identify the temperature zones; you will need a hotter section for toasting the buns and a cooler outer edge for keeping the butter warm without burning it.

Step 2: Prepare the Butter Bath

1. Place a small cast-iron skillet or a heat-safe sauce pot directly on the flat cooktop surface of the Arteflame.
2. Add the stick of butter and allow it to melt slowly. If using the smashed garlic clove, add it now to infuse the butter as it melts.
3. Once melted, move the skillet to a cooler part of the cooktop to keep it warm but not boiling. Stir in the fresh lemon juice and a pinch of salt.

Step 3: Toast the Buns

1. Brush the outer sides of the split-top hot dog buns with a small amount of the melted butter from your skillet.
2. Place the buns directly on the hot flat-top surface of the grill.
3. Toast for 1-2 minutes per side until they are golden brown and slightly crispy on the exterior, but still soft inside. Remove them from the heat and set aside.

Step 4: Warm the Lobster

1. Add the cooked lobster meat directly into the skillet with the warm butter.
2. Gently toss the meat to coat it thoroughly. You are not trying to cook the lobster again (which would make it tough), but rather just heating it through gently.
3. Let it sit in the warm butter on a cool zone of the grill for about 2-3 minutes.
4. Sprinkle in the Old Bay seasoning if you are using it.

Step 5: Assemble and Serve

1. If desired, line each toasted bun with a leaf of crisp lettuce (this keeps the bun from getting soggy too quickly).
2. Generously stuff the buns with the warm, butter-poached lobster meat.
3. Drizzle any remaining butter from the skillet over the top of the meat.
4. Garnish with the freshly chopped chives and serve immediately while hot.

Tips

Creating the perfect Connecticut-style lobster roll is an exercise in restraint and timing. The most critical tip is to ensure you do not overcook the lobster. Since you are likely starting with pre-cooked meat, the goal is merely to warm it up. If the butter is boiling, it is too hot; keep the skillet on the outer edge of the Arteflame where the heat is gentle. Furthermore, the choice of bread is non-negotiable. You must use New England-style split-top buns, which have flat sides perfect for griddling. Standard hot dog buns simply do not offer the same surface area for that crucial buttery crunch. Finally, use high-fat European-style butter if possible. Since butter is the primary sauce, its flavor profile will dictate the success of the dish. Clarifying the butter beforehand can also prevent milk solids from burning if your grill is running hot.

Variations

While the traditional recipe is divine, a few subtle tweaks can customize the flavor profile to match your specific palate or the theme of your cookout. The beauty of the Arteflame is that you can easily prepare different infused butters side-by-side on the cooktop to offer guests a variety of choices. However, try to keep the additions subtle so you do not overpower the delicate sweetness of the lobster meat. Here are a few ways to mix things up:

• Spicy Cajun Roll: Add a pinch of cayenne pepper and smoked paprika to the butter for a Southern kick.
• Garlic & Herb: Sauté minced garlic and fresh tarragon in the butter before adding the lobster for an aromatic French twist.
• Truffle Lobster Roll: Finish the assembled roll with a light drizzle of white truffle oil for an earthy, luxurious depth.
• Citrus Burst: Incorporate orange zest alongside the lemon juice for a brighter, more floral citrus note.
• Surf & Turf Style: Crumble crispy bacon bits over the top of the finished roll for a salty, smoky texture contrast.

Best pairings

A Connecticut-style lobster roll is rich and decadent, so the best sides are those that offer texture and acidity to cut through the butter. You want to avoid heavy, creamy sides that might compete with the lobster. Instead, opt for crisp, salty, or vinegar-based accompaniments. Since you already have the Arteflame fired up, utilize the grill space to prepare your sides alongside the main course. The contrast between the soft, warm bun and a crunchy side dish is essential for the full dining experience. Here are the ideal companions for your seafood feast:

• Kettle Cooked Chips: A classic salty crunch that is mandatory for an authentic seaside experience.
• Vinegar-based Coleslaw: The acidity cleanses the palate between buttery bites.
• Grilled Asparagus: Charred lightly on the Arteflame with lemon zest.
• Pickles: A dill pickle spear on the side adds the perfect acidic snap.
• Drink Pairing: A crisp Chardonnay or a cold Pilsner beer pairs perfectly with the rich butter.

Conclusion

Mastering the Connecticut-style lobster roll on your Arteflame grill is a rewarding culinary adventure that transports you straight to the New England coast. By swapping heavy mayonnaise for warm, liquid gold butter, you allow the lobster to truly shine as the star of the dish. The unique capability of the Arteflame to toast the buns to a perfect crisp while gently warming the butter bath ensures that every element is served at the ideal temperature. This recipe is more than just a meal; it is a celebration of fresh ingredients and open-fire cooking. Gather your friends, pour some crisp white wine, and enjoy the ultimate indulgence of hot, buttery lobster rolls right in your own backyard.