Grilling Lobsters: Is It Better to Grill More Small Ones or Fewer Large Ones?

2. Flavor and Texture

Small Lobsters:

• Tender Meat: Smaller lobsters often have softer, sweeter meat.
• Balanced Flavor: The smaller size ensures even cooking, reducing the risk of overcooking or undercooking.

Large Lobsters:

• Richer Flavor: The meat of larger lobsters can be firmer and slightly more flavorful, with a denser texture.
• Tail Dominance: Large lobsters yield substantial tail meat, making them ideal for those who love this part of the lobster.

Tip: If you’re prioritizing tenderness, go for small lobsters. For bold flavor and meaty portions, opt for large ones.

3. Cooking Time and Difficulty

Grilling lobster requires precision to avoid overcooking. Size plays a significant role in how long the lobsters stay on the grill.

Small Lobsters:

• Quick Cooking: Small lobsters grill in 6-8 minutes total, with 3-4 minutes per side.
• Ease of Handling: Their smaller size makes flipping and managing them on the grill simpler.

Large Lobsters:

• Longer Cooking: Large lobsters require 12-15 minutes, with careful monitoring to ensure even cooking.
• More Effort: Their bulk makes them harder to flip and position on the grill, and they may need indirect heat zones for even cooking.

Tip: If you’re grilling for a large group, smaller lobsters are faster and easier to manage.

4. Presentation and Serving

The size of your lobsters can impact the visual appeal of your meal.

Small Lobsters:

• Individual Servings: Smaller lobsters are ideal for serving one lobster per guest.
• Charming Presentation: A whole grilled lobster on a plate is visually appealing and feels personal.

Large Lobsters:

• Showstopping Centerpiece: A large lobster makes an impressive visual statement, perfect for special occasions.
• Shared Portions: Large lobsters are great for family-style meals where guests can share tail, claw, and leg meat.

Tip: For elegant, individual servings, choose small lobsters. For dramatic impact, go with large ones.

5. Cost Considerations

Size directly influences the cost of lobsters.

• Small Lobsters: Usually less expensive per pound, making them more budget-friendly for grilling in large quantities.
• Large Lobsters: Higher cost per pound, but their larger meat yield can be more economical for fewer guests.

Key Takeaway: Small lobsters are more affordable for group grilling, while large lobsters can be a cost-effective choice for smaller gatherings.

6. Grilling Tips for Both Sizes

Small Lobsters:

• Preheat the grill to medium-high (375°F-400°F).
• Split the lobster in half lengthwise, brush with melted butter, and grill flesh-side down for 3-4 minutes. Flip and grill for another 3-4 minutes until the meat is opaque.

Large Lobsters:

• Use a two-zone grill setup (direct and indirect heat).
• Start the lobster flesh-side down over direct heat for 5-6 minutes, then move to indirect heat to finish cooking for another 7-8 minutes.

Tip: Baste with garlic butter throughout grilling for extra flavor.

7. When to Choose Small or Large Lobsters

Grill More Small Lobsters If:

• You’re hosting a large group and need to serve many individual portions.
• You want tender, evenly cooked meat that’s easy to manage on the grill.
• Budget is a priority, and you want more lobsters for less money.

Grill Fewer Large Lobsters If:

• You’re aiming to impress with a stunning presentation.
• You’re cooking for a smaller group that values larger portions.
• You prefer richer, firmer lobster meat with a denser texture.

8. The Final Verdict: Small vs. Large Lobsters

When grilling lobsters, both small and large sizes have their merits:

• For quicker cooking, individual servings, and tender meat, small lobsters are the way to go.
• For dramatic presentation, larger portions, and bold flavor, large lobsters are the star.

Ultimately, the choice depends on your priorities—whether it’s efficiency, cost, or the wow factor. Whichever size you choose, grilled lobster is sure to be a hit at your next gathering.